Met Opera The Makropulos Case review

In a style that could almost be described as film noir, The Makropulos Case is a rare entry in the opera thriller genre.

The Makropulos Case Met Opera Karita Mattila.jpg

In a brisk prologue, men in hats and coats stand and stare at a giant billboard that is slowly revealed to carry an image of an exotically beautiful woman. A giant showcloth of crazed scrawlings drops in and, when the action resumes, we are in a stark law office with a towering window that looks out on the billboard.

Speaking of brisk, having been watching the Ring Cycle, it must be noted that this opera fairly flew by in comparison.


Success of this rarely performed work rests squarely on the shoulders of its leading lady and, fortunately, the Met is extremely well served by the luminous Karita Mattila. The lustrous, golden beauty of Mattila’s soprano is matched by her gorgeous statuesque physical presence. Like a pristine mature-age Marilyn Monroe, Mattila lights up the stage and thoroughly captivates the audience, her acting talent as extraordinarily strong as her singing.

Written well before the time of modern film scores, Janáček’s musical style presents the music as the type of accompaniment to the dramatic action, as heard for decades now in movies. The story progresses at a clipping pace, with the only casualty of this style being a distinct lack of arias. One longs to hear more than brief phrases, particularly from the marvelous Mattila. That chance finally comes at end, though still not in the form of a traditional melodic aria. Nonetheless, the music as a whole is entirely accessible and enjoyable on first hearing.

 Matthew Plenk, Emalie Savoy, Alan Oke

A very strong performance partner for Mattila in act one is powerful tenor Richard Leech as Albert McGregor. The famous opera singer Emilia Marty (Mattila) knows much of “Bertie” and his father’s will, despite the many years that have rolled by.

Leech, Jiri Belohlávek, Mattila, Johan Reuter

At first glance, act two appears to be set in a red floral garden, but one quickly realises that the turquoise cloud-strewn sky is a backdrop and the field of flowers are roses thrown on stage by Emilia’s ardent admirers. An increasingly rattled Emilia enters, wearing piercing emerald green, her strident behaviour that of a sexy siren. The action continuing on the opera house stage, we are soon under the gaze of another imposing female figure when the cloud cloth is struck, revealing a giant statue of the Sphinx. A huge red cloth flies in as past lover Count Hauk-Šendorf, a spry Bernard Fitch, recalls Eugenia Montez.

McGregor returns, having discovered a connection in the will to Elina Makropulos, rather than Elian MacGregor, and the evidence is clear of a woman who has lived across the ages with each new name having the initials E. M..

Tension and mystery build in act three until Emilia reveals all in a dazzling scene that finally gives Mattila an extended sequence of bravura singing. In the end there are probably too many male characters for them all to be presented clearly. The suicide of one young man has no emotional impact, except, as with all other elements related to the men, to colour and deepen Emilia’s fascinating character. Mattila’s tour de force performance in the finale is quite unforgettable.


The secret of her centuries on earth exposed, her long life becomes a cautionary tale as the magic formula is burnt. The omnipresent billboard goes up in flames to leave us with a final dramatic image at the end of Emilia’s tortured existence.


Photos: #1 Cory Weaver, #5 Ken Howard, all others: Simon Parris

Categories: Opera, Reviews

Tagged as:

3 replies »

  1. I told you it was good. I saw it again tonight. And you forgot to mention in your review — Emalie Savoy is hot.

    • Siggy! Thanks so much for the recommendation to see this. Was going to write a comment about this but you got in first.
      I actually lined up for a $20 rush ticket – bargain!
      I really enjoyed Makropulos and am so glad I saw it. Thanks again for recommending it to me.
      You’re right – Emilie Savoy was excellent. At least I included a picture of her – hope you liked it.
      Three more operas to go this week- second half of Ring Cycle #3 and Billy Budd. Reviews to come so stay tuned!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s