Music Theatre

Hamilton review [Melbourne 2022]

Australia’s theatre capital takes its turn to host the Room Where It Happens, as Hamilton arrives in sensational form, setting off a theatrical powder keg at Her Majesty’s Theatre, Melbourne.

With the benefit of a year of performances, albeit a somewhat interrupted year, an immediately noticeable aspect of the Melbourne season is the tremendous growth seen in the dazzlingly dynamic performances of the young cast members since the Sydney premiere. Stage presence, depth of character and palpable chemistry abound, enriching and enlivening the iconic work to its sizzling best.

Opening on Broadway in 2015, Hamilton’s world domination rapidly accelerated in 2016, when it won 11 Tony Awards, including, of course, Best Musical, and was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Drama. In the intervening years, the singular vision of deservedly adulated composer Lin-Manuel Miranda is yet to be matched, with Hamilton still the hottest ticket on the planet. 

Written for a US market, where theatregoers really know their country’s history, Hamilton works perfectly well as a stage spectacle but local audiences are advised to do a little pre-show reading so as to better appreciate the characters and context. Adding a degree of complexity is the fact that four of the lead players switch over to new roles in act two. These aspects are offset by the cast members’ heightened understanding of their characters and connections. This understanding enhances the storytelling clarity of Thomas Kail’s sharp direction, significantly assisting audience comprehension.

A further boost comes from the combination of the immaculate sound design and the pristine diction of the cast. Local fans may well have listened to the score countless times and watched the Disney+ filmed version on repeat, and yet they are bound to pick up any number of lyrics that they have never absorbed before. The lyrical leitmotifs and complex internal rhymes of Miranda’s lyrics can be enjoyed with ease, with the lead singers finding an abundance of unique expression and dynamics while making the roles their own.

Hamilton also looks beautiful on the stage of Her Majesty’s, a house renowned for the ready bond it facilitates between audience and performer. Kail’s direction and Andy Blankenbuehler’s choreography are performed with crisp precision, with surging waves of energy yielding to tender moments of quiet, all the while holding the audience enthralled and highly entertained.

Giving confident support to the cast as they perform a range of musical styles (it’s not all hip hop) is music director and conductor Laura Tipoki. Miranda’s music and the orchestrations of music supervisor Alex Lacamoire provide the genuine thrill of a live concert, converting newcomers to the addictive beats at first listen.

While the full ensemble cast has shown impressive growth, the most significant improvement has been achieved by Jason Arrow. WIth the strength of the title character now firmly in place, the whole show hums at a more exciting frequency. Arrow now has the role in his bones, so to speak, and can really lean into even the most rapid fire lyrics to bring out myriad quirks of expression, gentle humour and warm camaraderie. Arrow now conveys Hamilton’s life journey with distinction, providing a genuine centre of gravity for the men and women who swirl about him. Bravo!

Meanwhile, purring panther Lyndon Watts remains an utterly compelling stage presence, using his entire physicality to craft a scintillating characterisation. In Watts’ hands, Burr seems to practically conjure up act two showstopper “The Room Where It Happens” out of sheer will. The Salieri to Hamilton’s Mozart, Watts conveys Burr’s gnawing jealousy as a festering undercurrent that will not be quieted, convincingly letting the darkness overwhelm the man as he falls into his awful role in the story’s tragedy. 

With an endearing sparkle in his eye, Marty Alix charms in the dual roles of noble soldier John Laurens and cherished son Phillip Hamilton. Victory Ndukwe finds new levels in Lafayette and Jefferson, convincingly separating the two roles and proving plenty of appealing stage charisma. 

In the key role of Washington, Matu Ngaropo has a wonderfully commanding presence, his strong acting and terrific diction ensuring that key plot points land with abundant impact. Shaka Cook brings a subversive sense of rebellion to Hercules Mulligan, contrasting this effectively with the far more conservative James Madison in act two.

Akina Edmonds grounds Angelica Schuyler in compassionate warmth, neatly offsetting this with a lightly flirtatious air. Given precious little to do as Peggy Schuyler, Elandrah Eramiha shimmers in act two as sultry seductress Maria Reynolds, deftly conveying a healthy dose of doubt in the young woman’s mind under pressure from her reprehensible husband. 

At this performance, the role of Eliza was played by Tigist Strode. Strode’s youth may mean that Peggy does not really look like the youngest Schuyler sister, but Strode makes for a lovely Eliza, delivering a poignant rendition of delicate act two ballad “Burn” and closing the show with affecting sweetness and vulnerability in “Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story.” 

Looking every bit the brash, overgrown man-child, Brent Ashley Hill winningly wrings every delightful laugh from King George. 

As vital as any lead role, the ensemble works as a living, breathing unit, occasionally enjoying individual moments in the spotlight but generally blending seamlessly as one. Any individual player can be watched at any time, always focused, in character, singing soulfully and dancing with exceptional grace and strength. 

Prices are high, but Hamilton is worth every dollar. Melbourne’s legion music theatre lovers are set for a heady feast as Hamilton soars above the hype to deliver magical musical memories. 

Hamilton plays at Her Majesty’s Theatre, Melbourne. For tickets, click here.

Man in Chair reviewed the original Australian cast of Hamilton in Sydney

Man in Chair reviewed the original West End cast of Hamilton in London

Man in Chair reviewed the original Broadway cast of Hamilton in New York

Photos: Daniel Boud

6 replies »

  1. Watched Hamilton at HM Theatre Melbourne 6 April night and the four of us left at interval. Well back in the theatre under the balcony we could not understand the rapid-fire, rap type lyrics in the fast paced action throughout. Talk about a high profit margin show for the producers, nearly every setting was a repeat of the preceding ones, costumes and stills were the same throughout all the first half. Highlight was the performance by the King who was colourful and we could understand him plus he was slow and methodical in his movement and gestures. We really expected to be entertained, not subjected to a rather boring piece of American History. Worst live show I’ve ever been to. Whisperingjack

    • a visual and creative masterpiece. Truly a quality choreographed musical. well done Melbourne

  2. I was very much looking forward to Hamilton, given the numerous awards and accolades the performance has received. I attended April 6. I enjoyed it and acknowledge the talent of all involved, but I was not blown away. And I expected and wanted to be blown away. For a performance where the narrative was crucial to the telling of the story, I spent the first half trying to decipher the words. If there was pristine diction it must have gotten lost in the music. The second half was better and the use of hand held microphones improved it even more. Glad I didn’t leave at half time.

  3. I can’t understand the hype behind Hamilton. Yes I applaud taking a musical production in a different direction and I get the intent behind blending a historical scenario with contemporary music and also the deliberate casting decisions. My problem is, the execution.

    What seems bold and daring at first glance, lacks in delivery.

    The songs are repetitive and in some cases over long. The characters aren’t especially interesting or very 3 dimensional. The lyrics, whilst amusing at times, aren’t especially interesting either and lack the grit and polish of a true rap/hip hop performer. It’s like Eminem for your grandmother.

    That’s not to say the cast aren’t talented, they are, just the material they are working with felt like nothing special. Just because it’s done in a rap style don’t make it ground-breaking or even interesting. Kinda feels liek rap for rap’s sake.

  4. The sound and acoustics in the theatre were great and the positioning of the seats are nice and do not restrict the view of the stage. I enjoyed watching it from a higher platform as it gave me full view of the stage.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s