Music Theatre

StageArt: Dreamgirls review

Legendary Broadway musical Dreamgirls finally makes its Australian premiere in this flashy presentation from innovative, uncompromising independent theatre company StageArt.

DreamGirls, StageArt, Zenya Carmellotti, Anna Francesca Armenia, Thando Sikwila

A Tony-winning hit in the early 1980s, Dreamgirls is widely known from its high profile 2006 movie adaptation. If casting a full company of African-American performers deterred local producers from ever mounting the show, StageArt deserve extra credit for their vision in sourcing performers who not only look the part but are also highly talented.

The distinctly American story follows the swift rise and dramatic implosion of a girl group during the time that R&B music crossed over into the realm of popular music. Loosely based on Motown producer Berry Gordy and Diana Ross and The Supremes, the 1960s scenes throughout act one make for quite a thrilling roller coaster ride, while the 1970s problems faced by the characters in act two have a mellower edge.

Henry Krieger’s music captures a range of flavours, from R&B and soul to pop and rap, and music director Tyson Legg leads nine rocking musicians in bringing these styles to life. Vocal preparation is also very strong, with tight, smoothly blended harmonies a feature. Expert sound designer Marcello Lo Ricco ensures that Tom Eyen’s lyrics are clearly heard, a crucial factor in this largely through-sung show.

DreamGirls, StageArt, Zenya Carmellotti

Director Terence O’Connell has cast the show’s distinct characters extremely well, and propels the action forward with a cinematic flow between scenes. A good proportion of the blocking has performers facing forwards, but more of this is needed overall so as to allow a stronger connection between audience and performers. While younger members of the cast will surely gain in confidence as the season progresses, there was perhaps the need for more guidance in fully developing their characters and managing their energy and focus. Given the amount of acting, singing, dancing, costume and wig changing involved, it is an incredible result overall, particularly after only one preview performance.

A clear highlight of the production is Daniel Harvey’s creative, spectacular, intelligent costume design. The countless outfits not only look wonderful but are also a key aspect of the story telling, tracing the journey from homespun frocks to glamorous gowns, with some ingenious fast changes along the way. Lucy Wilkins’ wigs complement the styles perfectly. Some of the transformations achieved in the side stage wings would take hours in a photo shoot environment.

DreamGirls, StageArt, Zenya Carmellotti, Anna Francesca Armenia, Sharon Wills

Jacob Battista’s black scaffolding set design is not particularly inspired, but it does make amazing use of the small space. Acres of glittering black fabric give the venue the semblance of a proscenium arch theatre, somehow accommodating 19 performers and 9 musicians.

Choreographer Darren Stack performs miracles in the tight space available for movement, delivering crisp, well-rehearsed moves that are highly evocative of the era and are fun to watch.

Jason Bovaird’s multi-faceted lighting adds constant visual appeal, particularly during the concert numbers, and effectively transforms the single set stage to a range of locations.

In an extraordinary stage debut, Thando Sikwila is perfectly cast as Effie White, the troubled young woman whose natural talent is undermined by paranoia, both valid and unfounded. Sikwila captures Effie’s diva-like surly petulance as well as her doll-like sweetness when things go her way. Act one builds to all-time classic torch song “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going,” and Sikwila brings down the house, with resounding applause lasting through the next song all the way to the interval break.

DreamGirls, StageArt, Thando Sikwila, Anna Francesca Armenia, Zenya Carmellotti

As Deena Jones, talented young actress Anna Francesca Armenia is styled to closely resemble Miss Ross, also recreating the famous star’s winning smile with flair. Armenia sings the role well, and while her character’s promotion to lead singer is believable, later scenes call for a rise in diva-like vanity. This distinction is sure to develop as Armenia inhabits the role over the season.

Zenya Carmellotti is adorable as Lorell Robinson, projecting an engaging innocence and excitement as the eager young singer. The character of Lorell is lumbered with an extended act two scene with philandering partner Jimmy that is not all that compelling, but Carmellotti brings plenty spunk to her musical performances.

Canny casting choices delineate the range of male characters. As car salesman turned producer, Winston Hillyer has a commanding bass voice that strongly supports Curtis Taylor Jr’s authoritative manner. While his voice is highly expressive, Hillyer needs to cheat front far more often so as to engage with the audience and raise the impact of his character’s cheating and double-dealing ways.

DreamGirls, StageArt, Gareth Jacobs

Djon Alexander is excellent as C. C. White, Effie’s sweet song-writing brother who eventually stands up for himself to defend his contribution to the artists’ musical success. Gareth Jacobs is in terrific voice as egotistical R&B star Jimmy Early. Although Jacobs’ style has a crowd-pleasing edge, he does not quite nail the character’s self-assured, womanising ways. Augustin Tchantcho provides solid support as hard-edged long-term music artist manager Marty.

Small quibbles aside, this visionary production has great appeal. Music theatre aficionados should not miss this rare chance to experience Dreamgirls.

Dreamgirls plays at Chapel off Chapel, Melbourne until 14 June 2015

Photos: Belinda Strodder

Categories: Music Theatre, Reviews

4 replies »

  1. Hi Simon – saw Dreamgirls in LA with John Frost a few years back. Loved it and will go to see at Chapel off Chapel if I timing allows. I think this is a great venue that does very well. But my ‘favourite’ at this time is Hayes Theatre in Sydney – great Board – fabulous marketing of both the theatre and the shows. A lesson to many.

    John (known him long before he was Frosty and so hard to change) has now openly hinted at another large already produced musical from overseas for next year – but I am so thrilled that he is doing Dream Lover as appeared in Herald Sun earlier this week. A new Aussie musical I am happy to be involved with that following Simon Phillips workshop looks to be a hit (but don’t tell John I said this as I think he thinks such words jinxes the box office).

    Guess I will see you tomorrow evening at the Australian season opening of Anything Goes which I originally saw on Broadway many years ago.




    • Thanks for the update Barbara.
      John is certainly quite prodigious at the moment – so many shows on the books. I will be interested to hear about the next overseas one on it’s way..
      Keen to see Dream Lover when it finally arrives – great idea for a musical.
      Will look out for you at Anything Goes tomorrow. I saw it on Broadway a few years ago, but would love to have seen it many years ago! The Melbourne season in the 1980s was unforgettable. All those fabulous stars.
      Kind regards, Simon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s