Music Theatre

Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! in Cinemas review

I Cain’t Say No to watching Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma!, so this special cinematic release was the perfect way to spend a wintry Melbourne Sunday afternoon. 

The additional benefit of watching this gently innovative and yet completely respectful production again was the chance to help purge the memory of sitting through the execrable 2019 Broadway revival of Oklahoma!

Commemorating both the 25th anniversary of the production and the 80th anniversary of the musical itself, the global screening of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! is more than a celebration of the lasting power of this groundbreaking musical; it is a celebration of the life span of musical theatre itself. 

Premiering on Broadway in 1943, Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! Is generally considered to be the first of a style of entertainment that continues to thrive today. Moving on from revues, Oklahoma! was the first piece of musical theatre to successfully integrate book, songs, dance, and design to tell tell a cohesive story. It introduced the dream ballet, and was one of the very first shows to release a cast recording with the original stage production’s orchestra and cast. Oklahoma! pre-dates the Tony Awards, but in 1944 was awarded a special Pulitzer Prize. 

This screening commences with a ten-minute special hosted by Imogen Lloyd Webber, Senior Vice President of Concord, representing The Rodgers & Hammerstein Organization. This brisk, entertaining introduction places both the original record-setting season of Oklahoma! and the 1998 production in context. There are insightful interviews from key members of the 1998 team: choreographer Susan Stroman (currently represented on Broadway with New York, New York), Shuler Hensley (Jud Fry), and associate choreographer Warren Carlyle (who choreographed Oklahoma! stars Hugh Jackman and Hensley in Meredith Willson’s The Music Man on Broadway last year). 

This celebrated 1998 production of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! began at London’s National Theatre before transferring to the West End and then on to Broadway. Legendary director Trevor Nunn, of Cats, Les Misérables and Sunset Boulevard fame, directed the production, with choreography from Broadway’s Susan Stroman, of Crazy for You, Showboat and (later) The Producers fame. 

Nunn brought out the best in the much loved material by treating it with care and giving serious attention to the text. The sense of a plucky population waiting for their territory to become a state shines through, the distinction of farmers and cowmen is clear, and women have it all just as tough as men. To this end, Laurey is first seen in rough and ready overalls rather than the pretty dress of a traditional Broadway heroine. 

Placed against the hope of the people, Curly and Laurey’s romance is far more than a formulaic boy-meets-girl; the couple’s joy mirrors and amplifies the joy of their friends and family, who see a shining future for their state in this happy wedded union. There is strong impact in the action of the climax, which plays out with gritty realism, and there is no shying from the deadly consequences of the violence. 

A significant attraction of Stroman’s work here is that she was granted permission to create her own new work rather than recreating the original choreography of Agnes de Mille. Key numbers were re-orchestrated, including the “Dream Ballet,” which Stroman devised afresh. In what seems a simple and almost obvious idea now, Stroman had the vision to cut Dream Curly and Dream Laurey and have the actual actors dance their own roles in the ballet, to powerful effect.

While “The Farmer and the Cowman” is an especially lively and characterful full company number, the standout new orchestral arrangement and choreography comes in “Kansas City,” featuring a ragtime dance break that Will Parker has brought back home from city streets he visited in his travels.

In the mid-1990s, Australian theatregoers were fully acquainted with Hugh Jackman’s theatrical talents after his breakout performances as Gaston in the Australian premiere of Disney’s Beauty and the Beast and Joe Gillis in the Australian premiere of Sunset Boulevard. Jackman’s star turn as Curly in this production of Oklahoma! brought him to international attention and, although he went on to focus primarily on movies, he has starred on Broadway in hit seasons including The Boy from Oz (2003) and The Music Man (2022). 

Jackman makes for a ruggedly handsome, charismatic Curly and his baritone is wonderfully warm and engaging. Josefina Gabrielle deftly balances the plucky and vulnerable sides of Laurey, singing with a lovely soprano and dancing with lithe grace. 

National treasure Maureen Lipman perfectly captures the combined steely grit and affectionate compassion of matriarchal farm woman Aunt Eller. Shuler Hensley is suitably burly and creepy as embittered farmhand Jud Fry, with just a touch of vulnerability thrown in to garner a degree of understanding.

Jimmy Johnston dances up a storm as Will Parker. Vicki Simon plays Ado Annie with devilish innocence. Peter Polycarpou brings a sly twinkle to the eye of flirtatious peddler Ali Hakim.

Given the terrific singing and dancing talents of the ensemble, there is a surprising number of performers in the chorus and featured roles who look extremely authentic to the period and setting; this care in casting adds significantly to the genuine atmosphere.

Seen in a cinema, the filmed production plays very well, with judicious edits to skip across the scene changes and simply have the action flow on continuously. Cameras were clearly right in amongst the performers, with many compelling angles and shots achieved. A ten-minute interval allows a chance for a welcome stretch to break up the almost three-hour running time of the musical. 

Lovers of musical theatre are sure to appreciate this special screening, and are encouraged to take the chance to enjoy Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! in cinemas this week.

Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! plays in cinemas worldwide on 16 and 19 July 2023.

For worldwide access to Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Oklahoma! cinema tickets, click here.

Photos: supplied

8 replies »

  1. What a wonderful read Simon re this wonderful version of Oklahoma! I’ve been a big fan of it since first seeing it on tv many years ago. Your back story information is fantastic. One of the bonuses of this production is the re-instatement of the songs that were dropped for the much loved Hollywood outing giving ole Jud another moment to strut his characterisation. We have become used to Broadway/West End shows being splendidly filmed and presented in cinemas but I’m guessing this is an early example of the process whereby shows are filmed live with a dvd/streaming/cinema audience in mind to include edits, close-ups and adjusted lighting etc ?
    One sad point when I see Oklahoma ! is that ultimately the joyful characters would ultimately be tragically involved in the USA mid-west dust bowl depression of the 1930s.
    If you can …..please do more of these musical theatre cinema presentations…..that’s a big OK ! from me.

    • Thanks, Edward. You definitely should try to catch the next session of this screening on Wednesday.
      About the filming, it was to see that they had filmed with an audience there but there were also many scenes where they had clearly taken the cameras on stage to film interesting angles. This was presumably down without an audience being there. The end result is very cohesive and satisfying.
      Let me know your thoughts if you manage to attend on Wednesday.

  2. I agree with so much of your review – cast excellent (with a big hurrah for a superb Judd) – production and dancing terrific! But for me, the filming being mostly done on the stage without the audience was a bad decision. The (film) director ramped up the lighting throughout so the colours became very garish and there was a flat look generally that I didn’t feel did justice to the production. The sound had no subtlety and I missed hearing the audience reacting with laughter or applause, particularly at the end of each number. Just a tomb-like silence.
    NT Live has improved immeasurably in the last 25 years – no more big unwieldy film cameras, they’ve realised that an audience is 50% of what a stage show is about, and we see the subtleties of a live musical so much better.
    All that said – the film fascinates as a piece of theatrical history and a record of a brilliant production. Susan Stroman is a genius and I can’t recommend her 2023 production of Crazy For You at the Gillian Lynn theatre highly enough. The wonderful Charlie Stemp alone is worth the price of admission. And the show has so much much more besides!

    • Thanks for these comments, Tim.
      With the range of camera angles it was very noticeable that they had often filmed on stage rather than give us the audience’s viewpoint. Another example like this was when Love Never Dies was filmed on stage in Melbourne. Equally jarring.
      In regard to the silence, my friends and I in the cinema were applauding after each number, it definitely needed something there.
      I’m so jealous that London currently has the original version of Crazy for You. And with Charlie Stemp! Loved seeing him in Half A Sixpence and Hello, Dolly!.
      Maybe Crazy For You could be the next West End show to be filmed on stage…

      • Thanks for your kind remarks. Actually Simon thinking about it, the show was probably videoed with a concomitant degrading. So they’ve digitalised the old video which led to the flat look and even sound tones. Btw good tickets are to be had for Crazy for You at £18

      • I found out a little more about the filming of Oklahoma!. There was a period of around three weeks between the National Theatre season and the West End transfer. This gave time to film the show without the audience there. Some audience shots were filmed for the beginning and end.
        Not like the present day where shows are filmed and streamed to cinemas live!

  3. Loved : “my friends and I in the cinema were applauding after each number”
    I’m glad somebody else does this Simon ….I do it all the time ….even at the end of a non-musical movie that has been particularly good.
    I remember seeing the ‘That’s Entertainment’ movie in Los Angeles in the 70’s and the audience applauding after particular sequences, especially the dance numbers.
    I had not experienced this in Australian cinemas up to that time.

    • My early travels to the US I was amazed at the way audiences clapped at the end of a movie. I really like doing it, even though it is totally obvious that the artists can’t actually hear the applause! It just seems to be part of the cinema experience in the US, especially in LA where it is their local industry. I can only imagine how great it was to see That’s Entertainment in the cinema in LA!

Leave a comment