Music Theatre

MTC: Ladies in Black review

Utterly charming and original, new Australian musical Ladies in Black is cause for celebration.

Ladies in Black 2016 MTC

Nurtured and delivered by two state theatre companies, whose core business is straight plays, the surprise in the success of Ladies in Black is not so much that this happened at all but that it does not happen more often. Overseas, the subsidised or nonprofit theatre realm is often a melting pot for new music theatre work. Following this pattern, Ladies in Black should now be picked up by some lucky producer for a healthy commercial run. Fingers crossed that this will turn out to be the well-deserved outcome in this case.

While there are an infinite number of variables that have to fall into place for a successful new musical, the score is paramount. Ladies in Black not only skips the most common source for new musicals in Australia (the “jukebox”) but also significantly improves upon recent high profile new musicals King Kong and Strictly Ballroom by having the distinct voice of a score written by one composer.

In turning his hand to music theatre, Tim Finn joins a league of popular music writers turned musical composers that includes the likes of Elton John, Tim Minchin and Cyndi Lauper . Decades of experience in writing catchy hooks and narrative lyrics bear great fruit here, with a score that is enjoyably accessible on first listen. The snappy lyrics are witty, with many laughs coming from the delectable rhymes.

Stephen Sondheim’s Finishing The Hat may be a little aspirational for Finn’s sole background reference in his composer’s note, but he does acknowledge how high this sets the bar. And what Finn accesses here is an authentic Australian vernacular that only a local songwriter could achieve. Songs such as “He’s A Bastard” and “I Just Kissed A Continental” are a perfect tonal match for Carolyn Burns’ breezy book, the whole affair viewing 1950s Australia in a sunny, if not entirely rose-coloured, light.

Ladies in Black by MTC

The extensive experience of music theatre director Simon Phillips, also credited as dramaturg, has clearly been integral in shaping the work as a piece of music theatre. Finn delivers the requisite spread of songs, from establishing numbers, I wish songs, I am songs, patter songs, charm songs, ballads and production numbers. There is no climactic 11 o’clock number, just a reprise of “Can’t Wait until Tomorrow Becomes Today” as the characters, current issues resolved, continue to look to the future.

Based on Madeleine St John’s 1993 novel The Women in Black, the musical tells a snippet of the coming of age of a nation while ostensibly focusing the coming of age of intelligent young Lisa Miles. Working at David Jones Goodes department store the summer after finishing her Leaving certificate, Lisa’s excellent academic education is enriched with broader life experience as the stories behind the austere black outfits of her new workmates unfurl.
Ladies in Black MTC

Burns’ text deftly avoids the cultural cringe while shining a light on the expanding horizons of 1950s Australia. Entrenched sexism is mocked, and subtle points are made about overcoming the ongoing intertwined fear and racism against refugees. With Phillips’ input, the story is economically told with only ten actors. The doubling (or tripling) of roles works well, except for one anticlimactic sequence in which we do not actually see Magda’s New Year’s Eve party. Overlapping scenes, dream sequences and scenic dissolves are all handled with a supremely modern fluid touch.

Under David Young’s musical direction, the band sounds richer than only six players. This can be credited to clever orchestrations from master musician Guy Simpson.

Gabriela Tylesova’s scenic design is based on seven Perspex pillars, with a good portion of the budget perhaps going on the three stage revolves. Tylesova’s costumes are reliably sumptuous, providing a range of highly attractive cocktail and designer gowns. Featured gown the “Lisette” delivers a dreamy Cinderella moment.

Ladies in Black MTC 2016

Christen O’Leary makes a welcome return to the Melbourne music theatre stage as the exotic Magda. While some of the sales ladies dismiss Magda as “continental,” Lisa discovers the warmth and creativity of Magda and family. O’Leary radiates Magda’s generosity while maintaining an intriguingly mysterious air.

Ladies in Black MTC Christen O'Leary

The role of the gentle, sweet ingénue (think Cosette or Hope Harcourt) is a challenging one to make interesting. Sarah Morrison gives a lovely performance as Lisa, singing sweetly and forming genuine relationships with the women around her.

Experienced singing actress Lucy Maunder utilises her considerable talent to convey a large backstory to Patty, fleshing out the pain of young married woman whose marriage is threatened by fertility issues.  As Patty’s rather feckless husband Frank, Andrew Broadbent expands the role from a potentially one dimensional louse to a sympathetic, or at least understandable, man.

Naomi Price imbues the lovelorn Fay with a perky sense of hope. Bobby Fox is a great asset as the dapper Rudi, crooning a couple of comic ballads and fitting in some slick, fleet footed dance moves.

Ladies in Black MTC

Deidre Rubenstein creates the beautifully sympathetic role of lonely Miss Jacobs, bringing a distinct tenderness and kindness in her voice.

Strong support comes from fellow company members: Greg Stone as a pair of husbands, Carita Farrer Spencer as Lisa’s protective but gradually understanding mother, and Kate Cole and Kathryn McIntyre playing at least two roles each.

Ladies in Black plays at The Sumner, Southbank Theatre, Melbourne until 27 February 2016.

Ladies in Black was reviewed 8pm Wednesday 27 January 2016

Photos: MTC

12 replies »

  1. Are you kidding? Are you paid to give good reviews for such hollow, weak productions? Tim Finns music may be ok but the lyrics were embarressingly juvenile. No one close to me in the audience clapped most of the songs. I thought the show was cheap and relied too much on a fancy set and costumes. Was there a good voice on that stage? I would prefer that the MTV stuck to theatre and that they would respect their patrons by offering them some comfort in the theatre (my long legs were pressed against the seat in front and I was forced to behave like a jack in the box for some 20+ patrons getting in and out of their seats).
    Over all I found the production quite lacking in originality, quality music and inspired performance. No wonder Aussie audiences are flocking to the big screens when our own theatre companies are delivering such pedestrian productions!

    • No, I am not kidding and no, I am not paid for reviews. In fact, I bought my own ticket to Ladies in Black as I was away overseas when the opening night occurred.
      Leg room may be a little tight at the Sumner Theatre, but it is not as bad as a great many London theatres. The seats are comfortable and the sightlines are excellent.
      I am not sure if you like musicals so you might also prefer to stick to viewing the big screen.

  2. Hi Simon,

    I saw Ladies In Black last night and I was enchanted. Thank you for capturing the essence of this brilliant, clever show with your sensitive and considered review. The Saturday night audience loved LIB as much as I did.

    Nick Pilgrim

    • Thanks so much for this great feedback Nick.
      So glad you had the chance to see Ladies in Black, especially since you enjoyed it so much. It’s like they made creating a new musical not even look hard.
      I’d love to see it again – if only it was transferring to a commercial run. Imagine if they made a cast recording!
      Thanks again for your comments,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s